Episode 47
Paint by Number is Fine. A Coloring Book is a Threat!
In this episode which is sponsored by our wonderful partners at Inflow , I have a bone to pick with everyone who has ever bought me a coloring book. I know you meant well. I know you love me. I know you saw "mindless activity" and thought of me. But I need you to understand something: there is nothing in this world more stressful than being handed a mandala and a box of markers and being told to relax. Nothing.
Hi, I'm Lauren Howard and my friends call me L2.
Over the coming 20 minutes, I'll be walking through exactly why coloring books are a form of psychological warfare for my brain — the wrong colors, the spacing, the seven shades of gray problem, the blank page that is just failure waiting to happen — and what actually works for me instead. (Paint by number. With the paint pots included. Do not hand me a paint by number without the paint pots.)
I also tell the story behind why I sign off every single conversation — phone call, Zoom, hallway chat — the same exact way. Every time. Have for a decade. Started in a substance use clinic, where "be good" was less a pleasantry and more a genuinely urgent request. One patient called me out the one time I forgot. I didn't realize how much it had followed me until then.
Alison brings us a question from Simone in Oakland, California, who is frustrated by the advice to "listen to your body" because her body keeps sending contradictory signals — tired but wired, hungry but nauseous. I get into why that advice is genuinely incomplete, what those crossed signals actually mean, and when they're a sign something bigger needs attention.
"A blank coloring page is just a sheet of failure. Everything I do from here on out is going to be wrong. Get that thing away from me."
Be good.
Again, please do check out our episode sponsors Inflow at http://getinflow.io/notbroken
Chapters:
CHAPTER MARKERS
For use in podcast players and YouTube.
- 00:00 — Coloring book dread (the visceral reaction)
- 00:44 — Why people keep buying them (they mean well)
- 01:47 — Please stop buying me coloring books
- 02:30 — Mandalas, marker boxes, and wrong color panic
- 04:03 — The Golden Girls color-by-number disaster
- 05:17 — Paint by number: the acceptable alternative
- 05:22 — You're allowed to make ugly art
- 05:58 — Decision fatigue and the two-item menu
- 06:46 — The blank page nightmare (live in my living room)
- 07:53 — Where 'be good' actually came from
- 08:53 — The substance use clinic years
- 09:21 — The patient who called me out
- 10:57 — What 'be good' means now
- 12:38 — Small Talk with Alison
- 12:43 — Simone in Oakland: mixed signals from her body
- 13:05 — When 'listen to your body' is incomplete advice
- 16:42 — Dad's sign-off (and how I apparently inherited this)
Mentioned in this episode:
Join Quirky
Inflow
GetInflow
Our episode sponsor is Inflow. Please support this show and check them out at http://getinflow.io/notbroken
Transcript
I had like a visceral reaction to it. I was like, it just looks
Speaker:like failure to me. That is a blank sheet of failure.
Speaker:I say this as a person whose favorite playground is the fridge.
Speaker:If you're actually hungry and that makes you nauseous, you
Speaker:need to go talk to a doctor. And I was like, oh,
Speaker:I didn't realize you guys actually paid attention to that. All
Speaker:right, here we go. I'm gonna pretend I'm pushing record 'cause that feels right. Okay,
Speaker:I'm pressing record. Hi
Speaker:everybody, I'm Lauren Howard. Welcome to Different
Speaker:Not Broken, which is our podcast on exactly that—
Speaker:that there are a lot of people in this world walking around feeling broken, and
Speaker:the reality is you're just different, and that's fine. So
Speaker:I'm very fortunate to have lovely people in my lives—
Speaker:my lives? I have multiple lives apparently. My life. I have a singular life—
Speaker:who like to try to buy me things to help me
Speaker:relax or unwind because they know my life
Speaker:is in general very stressful and I do very complex,
Speaker:very complicated things all day. And so they do lovely, wonderful, sweet,
Speaker:kind things like buy me gifts. The one
Speaker:that I not get most often, but that I have gotten many, many times
Speaker:before is coloring
Speaker:books. Which I totally get, totally
Speaker:get, because it's supposed to be really relaxing
Speaker:and it's kind of a mindless activity. And you know, I'm a proponent for mindless
Speaker:activities and I love puzzles and I like paint-by-numbers.
Speaker:And so for Christmas and my birthday and stuff, a number of
Speaker:people have purchased coloring books for me.
Speaker:I think along that same vein, like, you like mindless things, so here's a coloring
Speaker:book. Please. Please
Speaker:don't buy me coloring books. I
Speaker:appreciate it so much that you would think about me and that you would
Speaker:want to buy me something, especially something that will allow me to
Speaker:relax and unwind. But I need you to understand that
Speaker:there is nothing in this world more stressful
Speaker:than a coloring book.
Speaker:It is, it is a, it is a
Speaker:book full of spaces. Actually, I
Speaker:take that back. The only thing maybe more stressful than a coloring book is if
Speaker:you were to give me a fully blank page and expect me to come up
Speaker:with something pretty. But actually, I think that might even be better
Speaker:because I can draw bubble letters and that's probably what I would draw because I
Speaker:was a child of the '90s. So, hmm. Like,
Speaker:coloring books often have very complex patterns. Or
Speaker:even not so complex patterns. And I have to—
Speaker:I have to pick colors to
Speaker:color in the spaces. And what if I pick
Speaker:the wrong color? What if it's not
Speaker:spaced out enough? You guys give me these books that have these beautiful
Speaker:mandalas in them that I want to color and I want to make beautiful.
Speaker:And then I sit and stare at my box of markers
Speaker:Like it is taunting me because I am supposed to pick one of
Speaker:them and know that it's
Speaker:the right color and that the color spacing will be correct
Speaker:and that I won't totally ruin it and
Speaker:that I won't put too many similar colors next to each other.
Speaker:And this is too stressful. It is too much
Speaker:pressure. I can't handle it. Okay?
Speaker:It's too much. This is not— this
Speaker:is not— this is not relaxing. I'm, I'm stressed just
Speaker:thinking about it, and I don't even have a coloring book in front of me.
Speaker:There are no colored pencils near me. There is nothing
Speaker:that needs to be filled in. Nothing.
Speaker:There— the expectations are too high,
Speaker:and I cannot deliver. Now,
Speaker:a paint-by-number or color-by-number, probably
Speaker:okay, but it has to, it has to
Speaker:have the actual colors you're supposed to use in the box
Speaker:or the package. Because my husband, being a lovely
Speaker:man who knows what I like, got me
Speaker:a Golden Girls color-by-number.
Speaker:And he, but it didn't come with, it didn't
Speaker:come with the markers. It didn't come with like any, nothing.
Speaker:So I had to take their color suggestions and find
Speaker:my own colors in my box of colors. I've got a
Speaker:lot of crayons and markers. Leave me alone. I'm a grownup. Anyway,
Speaker:I could, I spend my grownup money on markers. Bite me. But then
Speaker:the colors weren't like, then they didn't match exactly. And then, and
Speaker:then. Sophia Petrillo looked like a peach.
Speaker:It was just the wrong shade, and I didn't have enough—
Speaker:I didn't have enough different shades because, you know, you know that Blanche
Speaker:Devereaux was tan. You know she was.
Speaker:Sophia Petrillo was not. And so,
Speaker:like, even having the color by number that said, like, color this gray, I was
Speaker:like, which gray? I have 7 grays.
Speaker:Bought a lot of markers. Okay. So anyway, that did not work either, but
Speaker:a paint-by-number that literally comes with the little paint pots and they're marked with a
Speaker:number and I just have to— amazing.
Speaker:I can do that. I can handle that. Now I will say that I
Speaker:used to stress a lot because I would do my paint-by-numbers and they would not
Speaker:look like a Van Gogh because
Speaker:I have no artistic talent whatsoever. And it would break my heart
Speaker:that I didn't just pick up a cheap paintbrush that I definitely bought from
Speaker:Walmart and all of a sudden have the
Speaker:capacity to do impressionist art. That upset me.
Speaker:But I had a friend at one point tell me that it's— you're allowed to
Speaker:do things that you're not good at just because you enjoy them. And so I've
Speaker:just decided that I'm making ugly art and that makes me feel better. Like I'm
Speaker:just— that's the goal. The goal is for it to be ugly and then I
Speaker:don't feel bad about making it ugly because I'm not a skilled painter. If I
Speaker:was, I would not be filling in a box based on the number
Speaker:on a pot of acrylic paint.
Speaker:But the decision fatigue is high.
Speaker:And I— there are too many choices
Speaker:and I do not like choices. I want as few
Speaker:choices as possible. If there was a restaurant that had like
Speaker:chicken fingers or a burger, that would be my favorite restaurant. Not even because
Speaker:I want chicken fingers or a burger, but because on any
Speaker:given day I will know which one I want more.
Speaker:And there, and that it will be fine. Even if I don't want either that
Speaker:badly, I will know which one I want more.
Speaker:So that restaurant is my favorite restaurant because no
Speaker:thinking or very little thinking, limited thinking. Anyway,
Speaker:if you also struggle with coloring books, and I know there are others like this.
Speaker:Like me, my children were coloring the other day
Speaker:and our babysitter was sitting with them
Speaker:and she had her own coloring sheet, which she does not usually do. And
Speaker:as I walked past, she held it up with— it had no colors on
Speaker:it. She held it up and she was like, this is my nightmare. And I
Speaker:had like a visceral reaction to it. I was like, it just looks like
Speaker:failure to me. That is. That is a blank sheet of failure.
Speaker:Everything I do from here on out is gonna be wrong. Get that thing away
Speaker:from me. And she was like, exactly. She said, so if it's okay with you,
Speaker:I'm just gonna throw this out when I'm done with it, cuz I wanna, I
Speaker:wanna enjoy this time with the kids, but I don't wanna, I don't want any
Speaker:remnants of it. And then they were like, okay. So yeah, don't
Speaker:buy me coloring books because there is too much pressure
Speaker:involved in that.
Speaker:There's a coloring book right there. I was like staring at it as I was
Speaker:talking. I was
Speaker:like, I was trying to burn it with my eyes. I was trying to light
Speaker:it on fire like the burning bush
Speaker:coloring book. You know, it's kind of funny. I can't believe
Speaker:I don't sign off the podcast this way because like I have a very
Speaker:distinctive sign-off for the podcast, but literally I end every single
Speaker:conversation with somebody that has like a definitive ending,
Speaker:like a phone call or a Zoom, or even just like talking to somebody
Speaker:in person and walking away. Somebody I know, I don't know, not like my husband
Speaker:or my children, but like if I'm ending a conversation and walking away, I end
Speaker:it the same way, literally every single time, I don't even realize
Speaker:I do it anymore. Apparently I don't do it when I'm
Speaker:clowning and jackasses on the internet, but
Speaker:if you talk to me one-to-one, I do this every time.
Speaker:I'll say, hey, have a great day. Nice to talk to you. Be good.
Speaker:And then hang up. And I do it literally every
Speaker:single time. And I have for— I think I forgot that I do it. It's
Speaker:completely involuntary at this point, but it started.
Speaker:Very genuinely when I was running substance use clinics.
Speaker:So I run a mental health clinic now that is fully virtual, but for a
Speaker:long time I ran an in-person mental health and substance use clinic, and we dealt
Speaker:with a lot of patients who had recently gotten into a whole lot of trouble.
Speaker:And literally as they would leave every single time, I would
Speaker:say to them, be good. And it started as
Speaker:like kind of a joke, but also kind of a, like, I don't
Speaker:wanna see a mugshot of you between now and the next time I see you.
Speaker:Which was a thing that happened, not all the time, but it
Speaker:did happen. And so anytime they left, I would always say, have a good day,
Speaker:be good. So much so
Speaker:that one time I forgot to say it, not realizing that I said it that
Speaker:often. And one of my patients was like, I'm leaving. What are you supposed
Speaker:to say to me? And I was like, bye. And he
Speaker:was like, no. He was like, you're supposed to tell me to be good.
Speaker:And I was like, oh, I didn't realize that you guys actually paid attention to
Speaker:that. And he goes, I do pay attention to that and it matters to me,
Speaker:but I say it all the time. So it started out as an
Speaker:actual thing, like, please make good choices when you leave this place.
Speaker:Please pick up the phone and call me before you do a stupid thing.
Speaker:Please, you know, we have all the tools in the world for you. Be good.
Speaker:And if you feel like you can't be good, call me instead, uh, or call
Speaker:our office instead or whatever. And I mean, we're talking about thousands
Speaker:of patients over a 10-year period that I said it to. And so it, it
Speaker:just kind of became part of,
Speaker:part of what actually, I think it started as be good and don't do anything
Speaker:I wouldn't do. I, I used to say that to them all the time
Speaker:and that actually worked in that environment cuz I'm a tremendously boring person and I
Speaker:always have been. So like, it's not like I was ever leaving my office and
Speaker:getting into any kind of trouble that was interesting. Aside from like maybe
Speaker:mouthing off to somebody for being a jackal. Like other than that, there
Speaker:was nothing interesting happening, but then it was eventually just be good.
Speaker:And I have not run a substance use clinic in like 10
Speaker:years, but it's still stuck there and it still works. It still
Speaker:matters. It's still something that's really important to me because
Speaker:it doesn't matter what you're going through. I think when you, you know, when you
Speaker:are proceeding away from whatever conversation we're having, I
Speaker:want you to one, have a good day. I want you to two, make good
Speaker:choices. And 3, I want you to make the best of
Speaker:whatever is being presented to you from that point forward.
Speaker:And so it's, again, like I don't even realize I do
Speaker:it. It's fully pathological now, but if I don't
Speaker:say it, people catch me. And I actually had somebody comment on one of my
Speaker:LinkedIn posts the other day that I had, I guess we had talked and
Speaker:they, I didn't say it before we signed off and they were like, that was
Speaker:the first time you had ever not said it. And it was weird. And I
Speaker:was like, This has followed me around this
Speaker:far. Really? So anyway, I mean
Speaker:it. When you leave this place, be good. One, make good choices. Two,
Speaker:be good to other people. Three, be good to yourself.
Speaker:And four,
Speaker:you know, do something to give yourself the life that you wanna have that day.
Speaker:Be good. It is not, it does not mean be
Speaker:holy or pious or, or unfun.
Speaker:In fact, I support you in most of the debauchery that you will get into.
Speaker:I live vicariously through the debauchery that the people I care about get into.
Speaker:But if you ever, if you ever talk to me one-to-one, I guarantee
Speaker:you as a sign-off, it will come out. And I promise you, I don't realize
Speaker:it. And it is just part of my personality at this point
Speaker:is it started off as a way to encourage people
Speaker:who needed to make better choices to continue to make better choices. And it
Speaker:has just become fully ingrained in my psyche
Speaker:in a way that will never go away. And also
Speaker:other important things, other very important things.
Speaker:That is the way, that is the way that I sign off every single phone
Speaker:call. And now we'll
Speaker:go to Alison who has this week's Small Talk. We
Speaker:have a question from Simone in Oakland, California.
Speaker:I get frustrated when people say, listen to your body,
Speaker:because my body gives mixed messages. Tired
Speaker:but wired. Calm but anxious.
Speaker:Hungry but nauseous. How do you make decisions when the
Speaker:signals are all crossed? Somebody needs to have
Speaker:a talk with your body. That's not fun. That's,
Speaker:that's rude. Listen to your body isn't great
Speaker:advice at baseline. Like, it's, it's not
Speaker:bad. It's not bad advice. I, the, the intention is
Speaker:good. The intention is good, which is that
Speaker:there's a part of you that will tell you what you need and
Speaker:you should listen to that part of you. However,
Speaker:there are absolutely times when the wires get crossed.
Speaker:100%. There are times when the wires get crossed.
Speaker:No question.
Speaker:The reason I say that is if
Speaker:you were— if,
Speaker:like, there, there can be very serious conditions
Speaker:very serious acute episodes of something
Speaker:where you feel funny and your instinct is to go to sleep,
Speaker:right? Because you feel like rest is the way to handle it. Well, in
Speaker:those situations, rest could actually kill you, right? Because something
Speaker:horrific could happen in your sleep. Now, that's an extreme example of it,
Speaker:but there are times when our body tells us to do something that is
Speaker:decidedly not what the body needs to do. I'll give you an example.
Speaker:In the afternoon, when you are exhausted, when you're hitting your afternoon
Speaker:crash, taking a nap is not actually the way to handle
Speaker:the crash. The way to handle the crash, and this is me talking to myself
Speaker:more than anybody else, the way to handle the crash is to get up and
Speaker:walk around and move around and like get your heart rate up because that actually
Speaker:will wake you up. If you go take a nap, odds are you're gonna wanna
Speaker:take a much longer nap than what you needed, and then you're gonna be foggy
Speaker:after that nap, and it's not like it's not gonna be a restorative nap, right?
Speaker:But you're having a crash because you're in the middle of the, it's the middle
Speaker:of afternoon, your blood sugar's low, things are boring. The office you're in is probably
Speaker:cold. You're wearing a sweater that makes you warm. Like there's 10,000 reasons why you
Speaker:could be having a crash at that point. And your body is saying,
Speaker:or what you hear it saying is, I am gonna go lay down and rest.
Speaker:And in reality, it's you need to get up and walk around, talk to
Speaker:somebody, get, get the blood flowing, get a change of scenery, and then that's actually
Speaker:better for you. That's actually the better outcome for you. So definitely like
Speaker:that is you hearing one thing when your body's actually telling you something else. However,
Speaker:every single one of those things that you explained
Speaker:has a more prevalent
Speaker:need out of the two of them that you described, right? So you said
Speaker:tired but wired. Okay. Odds are there,
Speaker:you're tired. And you're probably
Speaker:tired because you're wired. So how do we overcome
Speaker:that part of it so that you can go to
Speaker:sleep? Like, there's a problem to fix there that's making you tired but wired.
Speaker:Same thing, hungry but nauseous. Like, you shouldn't be nauseous when you're hungry. There's a
Speaker:problem to fix there. Now, is it because you waited too long to eat?
Speaker:Do you need to eat more often? Because hungry is the emotion there.
Speaker:Now, if you're actually hungry and not bored, I say this as a
Speaker:person whose favorite playground is the fridge
Speaker:because I get bored and I go play there. If you're actually hungry
Speaker:and that makes you nauseous, you need to go talk to a doctor.
Speaker:But if you're hungry— if you're nauseous because you're hungry because you
Speaker:waited too long to eat, then you need to keep snacks with you and
Speaker:you need to eat them regularly because that shouldn't be happening either.
Speaker:So like the the two sides of those, there's a prevailing thing.
Speaker:There's a more important thing in each of the, the, the pairs that you
Speaker:mentioned. And you have to do, be able to do
Speaker:that first one. So you gotta figure out the second one
Speaker:and your body's definitely telling you something and it is probably telling you the first
Speaker:one. So we need to figure out why the second one is interfering.
Speaker:Thanks for being here, guys. Have a good day. Love you. Mean
Speaker:it.
Speaker:I am now remembering that my dad had a way that he
Speaker:signed off every single phone call that was the same regardless who he was
Speaker:talking to, and it was always, "Okay, thanks a lot, bye-bye."
Speaker:And it is making me laugh that I have now developed my own
Speaker:idiosyncratic way of ending phone calls.
Speaker:So as an end to this segment, Okay, thanks a lot. Bye-bye.
Speaker:And be good.
